Cedar shake roofs have been around for centuries—and for good reason. Known for their natural beauty, excellent insulation, and long-lasting performance when properly maintained, cedar shakes continue to be a top choice for homeowners looking for a classic, high-end roof system. But are they really worth it in today’s world of modern roofing materials?
In this guide, we break down everything you need to know about cedar shake roofs—how they perform, how long they last, how much they cost, and what to expect during installation. Whether you’re building a new home or considering a replacement roof, here’s how to know if cedar shakes are a good fit for your property.
What Is a Cedar Shake Roof?
A cedar shake roof is a type of wood roofing system made from natural cedar—typically western red cedar harvested in the United States or Canada. Unlike cedar shingles, which are sawn on both sides for a smooth, uniform look, cedar shakes are split by hand (or machine-split) to produce a more textured, rustic appearance.
Cedar shakes are available in a variety of styles:
- Hand-split and resawn for maximum texture
- Tapersawn shakes for a more refined finish
- 100% straight grain shakes, which resist cupping and warping better over time
The end result is a high-performance roof system that blends natural insulation with a warm, timeless aesthetic.
How Long Do Cedar Shake Roofs Last?
When properly installed and maintained, cedar shake roofs can last 30 years, sometimes even longer in dry climates. The lifespan depends on several factors:
- Installation quality: A skilled roofing contractor will ensure proper ventilation, underlayment, and fasteners.
- Cedar quality: Premium shakes are made from 100% straight grain cedar, which weathers better than flat grain.
- Climate: Cedar holds up well in many parts of the U.S., but frequent moisture or moss growth can shorten its lifespan without regular care.
- Maintenance: Cleaning debris, managing moss, and inspecting regularly will extend your roof’s life.
Compared to asphalt shingles, which typically last 15 to 30 years, cedar shakes offer significantly more longevity—especially when you invest in quality materials and live in a climate that supports natural wood performance.
What Are the Pros and Cons of Cedar Shake Roofs?
Pros
- Natural insulation: Cedar is an excellent insulator, helping to regulate indoor temperatures and reduce energy use.
- Curb appeal: The rustic, hand-split look adds character and charm that’s hard to replicate with synthetic materials.
- Sustainability: Cedar is a renewable resource when harvested responsibly.
- Durability: Resistant to wind, impact, and UV damage—especially when installed by an experienced team.
Cons
- Higher upfront cost: Cedar shake roofs are a premium product, often costing more per square foot than asphalt or some metal roofing options.
- Maintenance requirements: These roofs require periodic cleaning, sealing, and moss removal to maintain peak performance.
- Fire risk: Unless treated, natural cedar is not inherently fire-resistant (though Class A fire-rated options are available).
For many homeowners, the aesthetic payoff and long-term durability far outweigh the maintenance needs.
How Much Do Cedar Shake Roofs Cost?
The cost of a cedar shake roof varies by region, materials, and installation complexity, but you can expect to pay between $10 and $20 per square foot installed.
That includes:
- High-quality cedar shake shingles
- Underlayment and flashing
- Labor from a licensed roofing contractor
- Additional treatments (fire retardant, sealants) if needed
Keep in mind: higher upfront investment often translates to longer lifespan and lower long-term costs when compared to cheaper roofing materials that may need more frequent replacement.
What’s Involved in Installing a Cedar Shake Roof?
Installing cedar shake is a highly specialized process that requires craftsmanship and precision. The shakes must be spaced and layered correctly to ensure ventilation, drainage, and water resistance.
Here’s what goes into a typical installation:
- Tear-off (if applicable): Removing your old roofing material
- Prep and underlayment: Installing waterproof barriers and breathable underlayment
- Shake installation: Hand-placing each shake with staggered gaps and secure fasteners
- Ventilation: Ensuring airflow beneath the shakes to prevent moisture buildup
- Finishing touches: Ridge caps, flashing, and gutter integration
Choosing a roofing contractor with experience in installing cedar shake is essential. Poor installation can drastically reduce performance and shorten the roof’s life.
Are Synthetic Cedar Shake Roofs a Good Alternative?
Yes—for some homeowners, a synthetic cedar shake roof offers a great middle ground. These products are designed to mimic the look of hand-split wood shakes using composite materials that resist rot, fire, and pests.
Benefits of synthetic cedar shakes include:
- Lower maintenance
- Longer warranties
- Fire and impact resistance
- More consistency in appearance
However, they don’t always capture the full character of natural cedar shake, and not all synthetic products are created equal. If you love the authenticity of natural wood, real cedar may still be the better option—especially when installed by a trusted professional.
Frequently Asked Questions About Are Cedar Shake Roofs Good?
Are cedar shake roofs high maintenance?
They do require more maintenance than asphalt or metal roofs. Expect to remove moss, clean gutters, and check for signs of wear every year or two. However, the payoff is a long-lasting and beautiful roof system.
Do cedar shake roofs improve energy efficiency?
Yes. Cedar is naturally insulating and can help reduce heating and cooling costs by maintaining a more stable indoor temperature.
Are cedar shake roofs fireproof?
No—but many manufacturers offer fire-treated cedar shakes that meet Class A fire resistance standards. This is essential in fire-prone areas or where local building codes require it.
Can cedar shake roofs handle heavy rain or snow?
Absolutely, as long as they are properly installed with correct flashing, ventilation, and drainage. Cedar is naturally water-resistant and holds up well in wet climates when maintained.
Is cedar roofing a good investment?
If you’re looking for a roof that offers curb appeal, long lifespan, and strong performance, cedar shakes are a solid investment—especially when combined with high-quality materials and expert installation.
Talk to Warner Roofing & Construction About Cedar Shake Roofs
Cedar shake roofs aren’t just good—they can be exceptional when installed and maintained correctly. If you’re considering cedar for your next roofing project, Warner Roofing & Construction brings decades of craftsmanship, training, and experience to ensure the job is done right.
Reach out to Warner Roofing today to ask your cedar shake questions, explore other roofing options, or discuss roof installations that suit your home and your goals.
